Everything Music. Everything News. Everything live.

Don Henley, Irving Azoff Sued Over Handwritten Lyrics

Dana Nalbandian / shutterstock.com
Dana Nalbandian / shutterstock.com

Don Henley, co-founder of the iconic rock band the Eagles, and his manager, Irving Azoff, are being sued by rare book dealer Glenn Horowitz. Horowitz, previously accused of attempting to sell stolen handwritten lyrics from the Eagles' legendary album “Hotel California,” has filed a lawsuit against Henley and Azoff, ardently claiming they falsely accused him and subsequently caused significant damage to his reputation and business. This case stems from a long-standing saga over the ownership and provenance of the handwritten lyrics, which have traversed a convoluted journey over several decades.

Originally accused in 2022, Horowitz, along with co-defendants Craig Inciardi and Edward Kosinski, faced criminal charges connected to the sale of these lyrics. The charges, however, were dropped in 2024 after it came to light that Henley and Azoff's legal team had withheld critical evidence that could have exonerated the defendants earlier in the process.

The roots of this controversy trace back to an arrangement in 1979 when Henley hired author Ed Sanders to write a never-published memoir about the band. According to court filings, Sanders claimed to have acquired the handwritten lyrics with Henley's consent. After the project was abandoned, Sanders reportedly retained these notes, which eventually ended up with Horowitz in 2005. This chain of custody is the crux of Horowitz's defense – that the lyrics were not stolen, but rather legally acquired from Sanders.

Horowitz alleges that Henley and his legal counsel purposefully obscured the truth, leveraging attorney-client privilege to withhold approximately 6,000 pages of potentially exculpatory emails during the initial trial. This alleged suppression of evidence played a pivotal role in the Manhattan District Attorney's decision to dismiss the case, with prosecutors acknowledging that crucial information had been intentionally withheld by Henley's team.

Moreover, Horowitz claims significant damages from what he describes as an “unjust prosecution.” His lawsuit details the extensive professional and personal harm he suffered, citing losses exceeding ten million dollars due to diminished business prospects and reputational damage, alongside severe emotional and financial distress experienced by him and his wife. Despite the charges being dropped, Henley, Azoff, and their legal teams have maintained their stance, describing Henley as a victim of illicit memorabilia sales and defending their course of action as an effort to reclaim Henley's intellectual property wrongfully taken and sold.

Critically, Henley's attorney, Dan Petrocelli, has described Horowitz's lawsuit as the only instance of malicious prosecution in this affair, portraying Henley as a rightful owner trying to protect his property. Meanwhile, Horowitz's attorney, Caitlin Robin, asserts that the evidence supports their claims of legal acquisition, implying that Henley and Azoff's accusations were knowingly false and pursued with unjust intent.

This ongoing legal drama continues to attract widespread attention, underscoring the complex issues surrounding entertainment law and intellectual property rights. As Horowitz seeks reparations in his suit against Henley and Azoff, the case propels discussions on the responsibilities and ethical obligations of preserving and representing artistic legacies accurately and honorably. The final judicial determinations in this case will likely have significant ramifications for how similar disputes are navigated in the future.

Key Takeaways

Related Stories

Iggy Pop Gucci and Snap Inc. Host :Private Event Featuring the Debut of Harmony Korine's New Film, Duck Duck, The Melin Building, Miami, FL - 04 Dec 2019

Iggy Pop’s Deep Cut Plays During End Credits of Superman

The latest installment in the Superman franchise, directed by James Gunn, has not only stirred excitement due to its creative…

Bob Dylan in concert during the Sturgis Motorcycle Rally, Buffalo Chip Campground, Sturgis, South Dakota, America - 10 Aug 2010

Bob Dylan Announces 2025 UK & Ireland Tour Dates

Renowned musician and songwriter Bob Dylan has officially confirmed his highly anticipated 2025 UK and Ireland tour. This announcement forms…

Paul McCartney Paul McCartney in concert in Perth, Australia - 02 Dec 2017 Iconic singer, songwriter and performer Paul McCartney performs at NIB Stadium in Perth, Australia, 02 December 2017. His 'One on One' tour is his first tour of Australia since 1993.

Paul McCartney Unveils 2025 North American Tour Dates

Paul McCartney, an enduring icon of the British invasion and co-founder of the legendary Beatles, is poised to captivate audiences…

Ozzy Osbourne Photographed Live at Irvine Meadows Ampitheater in Irvine Ca On August 3 1989 On the 'No Rest For the Wicked' Tour Ozzy Osbourne - 1989

Ozzy Announces ‘Last Rites’ Memoir

Ozzy Osbourne, the legendary heavy metal icon known as “The Prince of Darkness,” is gearing up for the release of…

Black Sabbath - Ozzy Osbourne Black Sabbath in concert, Denver, Colorado, America - 15 Feb 2016

Ozzy Osbourne Will Auction Off Paintings He Made With Chimps

Ozzy Osbourne, the venerable icon of heavy metal and former frontman of Black Sabbath, has once again captured public attention,…

Kim Metso, CC BY-SA 3.0 , via Wikimedia Commons

Jens Lekman Announces Tour, New Album & Shares Video for New Song

Jens Lekman, the acclaimed Swedish singer-songwriter, is set to return with his much-anticipated new studio album titled Songs for Other…

NCT 127 - Taeyong, Taeil, Yuta, Jaehyun, Winwin, Mark and Haechan Poptopia presented by 99.7 NOW, San Jose, USA - 05 Dec 2019

Former NCT Member Taeil Found Guilty of Rape, Sentenced to 3+ Years

The K-pop scene has recently been jolted by a significant legal case involving former NCT member, Taeil. The 31-year-old singer,…

Headline Act Paul McCartney performs on the Pyramid Stage during day four of Glastonbury Festival Glastonbury Festival, Day 4, UK - 25 Jun 2022

Paul McCartney Teases a 2025 Tour

In an exciting revelation that is sure to stir fans worldwide, Sir Paul McCartney is teasing the potential revival of…

Roger Waters, bassist, songwriter and former member of the rock band Pink Floyd performing on stage in Bologna, April 28, 2023, Italy, during his european tour. Photo Michele Nucci. Music Concert - Roger Waters - Farewell Tour, Bologna, Italy - 28 Apr 2023

Roger Waters Risks Jail Time During Political Protest

Roger Waters, former member of the iconic rock band Pink Floyd, finds himself at the center of legal controversy following…