Everything Music. Everything News. Everything live.

Steven Tyler, Accuser Julia Holcomb Clash Over Abortion Evidence Ahead of Trial

Steven Tyler (40704267772)
© Gage Skidmore from Peoria, AZ, United States of America / CC BY-SA 2.0 via Wikimedia Commons

Aerosmith singer Steven Tyler and his accuser Julia Holcomb are locked in a pretrial fight over what evidence jurors will be permitted to hear, according to newly filed court documents. At issue is whether two abortions Holcomb underwent in the 1970s can be introduced during the upcoming trial in her sexual abuse case against Tyler.

Holcomb has alleged that Tyler abused her sexually when she was a teenager during the 1970s, stating that their relationship began when she was 16. Tyler has denied any wrongdoing in connection with her claims.

What the Court Filings Say About the 1975 and 1979 Abortions

Tyler’s attorneys are seeking to keep any mention of a 1975 abortion out of the trial entirely. Their argument is that the procedure took place in Massachusetts, after Holcomb had already turned 18, and therefore has no bearing on the alleged sexual conduct that occurred in California.

Tyler’s side has acknowledged that the 1975 pregnancy would have been his own child. His legal team has said that if the judge decides to let jurors hear about that abortion anyway, Tyler wants the option to also present evidence of a second abortion Holcomb had in 1979, during a pregnancy involving a different man.

  • Holcomb alleges the relationship with Tyler began when she was 16 years old, in the 1970s.
  • The 1975 abortion occurred in Massachusetts, after Holcomb turned 18.
  • The 1979 abortion involved a pregnancy with another man’s child.
  • A ruling from the judge on the evidence dispute has not yet been issued.

Why Tyler’s Lawyers Want the Second Abortion Included

According to the filings, Holcomb has described the 1975 abortion as deeply traumatic and has pointed to it as a source of the emotional distress damages she is pursuing in the lawsuit. Tyler’s attorneys argue that if that claim is allowed to stand before the jury, fairness requires that the 1979 abortion also be introduced so jurors have full context.

The filings also note that Holcomb has appeared as a speaker within anti-abortion circles, where she discussed regret over having undergone an abortion in general terms rather than tying those remarks specifically to the 1975 procedure. Tyler’s lawyers contend this broader history is relevant to understanding her emotional distress claims.

Tyler’s legal team has argued that because Holcomb has acknowledged both abortions were traumatic for her, the 1979 procedure could represent an alternative explanation for her alleged emotional and mental distress, separate from anything connected to Tyler. As of the latest filings, the judge overseeing the case had not yet ruled on whether either abortion can be presented to the jury.

More Info

  • Aerosmith Steven Tyler’s Accuser Fighting to Keep Abortion Evidence Out of Court | TMZ Music

Related Stories

Geddy Lee Fires Back at Critics Who Say Rush Hired Anika Nilles Over a ‘Woke Agenda’

In a new interview with The Telegraph, Rush’s Geddy Lee pushed back hard on claims that drummer Anika Nilles was brought in to fill a diversity quota rather than Neil Peart’s drum stool.

Kid Rock’s Nashville Bar Sued Over Alleged Elevator Beating of Patron

A patron is suing Kid Rock’s Big Ass Honky Tonk Rock N’ Roll Steakhouse in Nashville, claiming security guards beat him in an elevator after he touched a performer’s guitar.

KISS Leads All-Star Ace Frehley Tribute Concert at Las Vegas KISS Kruise

Paul Stanley, Gene Simmons, Tommy Thayer and Eric Singer joined Ace Frehley’s solo band and a roster of guest musicians for an 11-song tribute to the late KISS guitarist in Las Vegas.

Iron Maiden Inducted Into Rock and Roll Hall of Fame

Iron Maiden joined the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame’s 2026 class without a single band member present, as Jack Black, St. Vincent and musicians from Metallica, Rage Against the Machine and Motley Crue stepped in to perform ‘The Trooper.’

Roger Waters Files for Divorce from Fifth Wife Kamilah Chavis After Five Years of Marriage

Roger Waters, 83, has filed for divorce from Kamilah Chavis, 48, in New York Supreme Court, closing out his fifth marriage after five years together.

Duran Duran Drummer Roger Taylor Retires, Citing Worsening Tinnitus

Duran Duran drummer Roger Taylor announced on November 12, 2026 that he is retiring from drumming and leaving the band after a worsening tinnitus diagnosis, with bandmates Simon Le Bon, Nick Rhodes and John Taylor voicing full support.

Stewart Copeland Announces 2027 ‘Police Deranged for Orchestra’ World Tour

Stewart Copeland has announced a 2027 world tour that reworks The Police’s catalogue with a 28-piece orchestra, timed to his 75th birthday and the band’s 50th anniversary.

Paul McCartney, Ringo Starr to Reunite at Joe Walsh’s VetsAid 2027 in Las Vegas

Paul McCartney and Ringo Starr are scheduled to join Joe Walsh for a joint performance at VetsAid 2027, a veterans benefit concert set for the MGM Grand Garden Arena in Las Vegas.

Phil Collins Hints He May Tour Again, But Says Money Is the Real Obstacle

Days before entering the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame as a solo artist, Phil Collins says he still occasionally thinks about returning to the road, though he insists the math on a short tour just doesn’t add up.