Everything Music. Everything News. Everything live.

Sammy Hagar Calls Alex Van Halen’s Ommision of ‘Van Hagar’ Era Blasphemy

Sterling Munksgard / Shutterstock.com
Sterling Munksgard / Shutterstock.com

Sammy Hagar, the former frontman of the legendary band Van Halen, recently took to social media to criticize his former bandmate Alex Van Halen for neglecting a significant era of the band's history in his recently published memoir, ‘Brothers.' The book, which explores the band's journey, focuses primarily on the years with David Lee Roth as the lead vocalist and omits the period when Hagar was the frontman. This oversight did not sit well with Hagar, who publicly called it “blasphemy” to Eddie Van Halen’s legacy, a statement that has sparked considerable controversy among fans and in the rock music community.

The revelation comes with the release of Van Halen's Memoir ‘Brothers,' which details the band's history up until 1985, when David Lee Roth left the group. Notably absent from the memoir is any mention of Hagar’s decade-long tenure with the band, which led to four number-one albums and significant commercial success. During this period, known as the “Van Hagar” era, the band sold over 50 million records worldwide and dominated stadium stages for years. Hagar, clearly frustrated by this omission, responded to fans' comments on social media, affirming that while purists might prefer the Roth years, the band achieved unprecedented success during his time as frontman.

Hagar, known as the “Red Rocker,” has not only defended his contributions to the band during this era but also shared on his Instagram a nostalgic photo of himself with Eddie Van Halen. The caption, which reflected on the “good old days” of performing together, resonated deeply with fans who appreciate the band's entire history, not just its early years. In interviews, Hagar has expressed a desire to reconcile with Alex Van Halen, acknowledging that capturing the entire history in one book might have been a challenging feat and suggesting the possibility of a future volume that could address the gaps.

Critics of ‘Brothers' have pointed out that the exclusion of the “Van Hagar” era reflects more than just a personal oversight; it raises questions about how band members perceive different phases of their history. Alex Van Halen, in interviews promoting ‘Brothers,' stated his preference for the original lineup, which he felt captured the essence and magic of Van Halen. He referred to the post-Roth years as a distinct chapter that did not align with the raw rock and roll identity established earlier. This polarizing view is at the heart of the current tensions between Hagar and Alex, igniting debates over what truly defines the band’s legacy.

In addressing these disputes, Hagar has also acknowledged his personal aspirations to mend ties with his former bandmate for the sake of honoring Eddie Van Halen's memory. He expressed a wish to resolve their differences, so neither he nor Alex carries these issues to their graves. This sentiment of reconciliation underscores Hagar's perspective that the band's legacy, regardless of its lineup changes, should be a celebrated continuum rather than dissected parts defined by individual members’ preferences or histories.

Looking forward, Hagar remains committed to celebrating his musical past and honoring Eddie's legacy. He has planned a Las Vegas residency with his band, Best of All Worlds, featuring renowned musicians like Joe Satriani, to honor Van Halen's music. Moreover, Hagar announced the upcoming release of a tribute song for Eddie, further asserting his dedication to preserving the band's enduring impact. Through these events, he intends to keep the spirit of Van Halen alive for fans who appreciate both the classic and “Van Hagar” tracks.

Key Takeaways

Related Stories

Rick Derringer in concert at the Pompano Beach Seafood Festival, Florida, America - 27 Apr 2013

Rick Derringer, Legendary Rock Guitarist Dies At 77

The music world mourns the loss of legendary rock guitarist Rick Derringer, who passed away at the age of 77.…

Ed Droste of Grizzly Bear at Bonnaroo Music and Arts Festival on June 12, 2009 in Manchester, Tennessee Grizzly Bear at Bonnaroo Music and Arts Festival on June 12, 2009 in Manchester, Tennessee, Bonnaroo Music and Arts Festival, Manchester, TN, USA - 12 Jun 2009

Grizzly Bear Announces 2025 North American Tour

Grizzly Bear, a staple of the indie-rock genre, is making a highly-anticipated return to the concert stage following a six-year…

Stereolab Primavera Sound Festival, Barcelona, Spain - 01 Jun 2019

Stereolab Returns with New Album After 15 Years

Stereolab’s return with their new album Instant Holograms On Metal Film marks a triumphant resurgence for the band, offering fans their…

Neil Young performs during Farm Aid 2019 'Farm Aid', Alpine Valley Music Theatre, East Troy, Wisconsin, USA - 21 Sep 2019

Neil Young Performs ‘My Boy’ for First Time in 42 Years

Neil Young, the iconic Canadian singer-songwriter, captivated audiences with a memorable performance on May 23, 2025, showcasing his ability to…

, via Wikimedia Commons

Violinist & Keyboardist Simon House Dead at 76

The music industry is mourning the loss of Simon House, a renowned violinist and keyboardist celebrated for his groundbreaking work…

Modest Mouse Mad Cool Music Festival 2022 in Valdebebas, Madrid, Spain - 08 Jul 2022

Modest Mouse Announces 2025 Tour

Modest Mouse has revealed an extension of its busy 2025 tour schedule with a highly anticipated North American fall tour.…

Lainey Wilson 2025 American Music Awards, Show, Las Vegas, Nevada, USA - 26 May 2025

Lainey Wilson Debuts New Song at 2025 AMAs

In an electrifying and heartfelt performance, Lainey Wilson delivered her new song, “Somewhere Over Laredo,” at the 2025 American Music…

Freddie Mercury Queen in concert at Wembley, London, UK - Sep 1984

Book Claims Freddie Mercury Had A Secret Daughter

In a sensational development about the renowned Queen frontman, Freddie Mercury, a recently published biography titled Love, Freddie: Freddie Mercury’s…

Billy Joel live in concert, Hamburg, Germany 1990. // Billy Joel live in concert, Hamburg, Deutschland 1990. Billy Joel Live in Concert - 16 May 1990

Billy Joel Cancels Tour After Brain Diagnosis

Billy Joel’s announcement of canceling all his upcoming concerts has shocked and saddened fans around the globe. The legendary musician…