Everything Music. Everything News. Everything live.

Court Finds in Favor of Filmmaker in Roger Waters Defamation Case

Originaltm, CC BY 4.0 <https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0>, via Wikimedia Commons
Originaltm, CC BY 4.0 , via Wikimedia Commons

Pink Floyd's former bassist Roger Waters is facing serious legal troubles following a defamation lawsuit brought forward by filmmaker John Ware. The controversy arose from comments Waters made during an interview with Al-Jazeera. Waters accused Ware of being a “Zionist mouthpiece” and of “cheerleading the genocide of Palestinians.” These allegations were connected to Ware's documentary, The Dark Side of Roger Waters, which chronicles allegations of antisemitism against the musician. Waters claimed the documentary lacks foundation and aims to misrepresent him, a defense that did not hold in court.

The court found that the controversial member of Pink Floyd defamed filmmaker John Ware, establishing that Waters' remarks amounted to statements of fact rather than mere opinions. Justice Jennifer Eady articulated that although Waters's use of the term “genocide” might have reflected his opinion about Israeli forces' actions in Gaza, claiming that Ware supported genocide was a factual assertion. This legal interpretation was central in not allowing Waters to evade responsibility by framing his utterances as opinion.

As the case progresses towards trial, the public spotlight is likely to shine even more on the issues discussed in the documentary. The Dark Side of Roger Waters does not merely delve into Waters' career but also examines his alleged antisemitic tendencies. The film includes testimonies from various people who have engaged with Waters during his career, including former collaborators. Waters, who has been a vocal critic of Israeli policies, insists his critiques are directed towards the state rather than Judaism. However, his choice of words and actions, such as allegedly downplaying attacks attributed to Hamas and their implications, have not helped his public image.

This legal battle highlights issues of free speech and the limits placed on public figures when making claims about others. Waters has pushed back against accusations, maintaining that his commentary was in the domain of political expression rather than personal attacks. However, the court's dismissal of this defense to categorize his comments as defamatory suggests a tightening of what may be considered permissible speech when it comes to sensitive cultural and political issues.

Waters has been no stranger to controversy, with previous run-ins over his statements and actions viewed by some as antisemitic. Most notably, German authorities launched investigations into Waters for wearing controversial Nazi-like costumes during performances in Berlin. Moreover, his former bandmate David Gilmour and Gilmour's wife have publicly criticized Waters for his views, adding another layer to his contentious public persona.

 

Key Takeaways

Related Stories

Bad Company - Mick Ralphs Bad Company in concert at Jiffy Lube Live in Bristow, Virginia, America - 14 Jul 2013

Bad Company Guitarist Mick Ralphs Dies at 81

Mick Ralphs, a distinguished guitarist and songwriter, was at the heart of two of Britain’s seminal rock bands, Bad Company…

Masta Killa of Wu Tang Clan Lovebox Festival, Gunnersbury Park, London, UK - 13 Jul 2018

Wu-Tang Clan’s Masta Killa Says You Should Go Vegan in New PETA Spot

In a notable collaboration with People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA), Masta Killa, a distinguished member of the…

LEFT PHOTO: Turnstile in concert at Under the K Bridge in Brooklyn, New York, USA - 05 Jun 2025 RIGHT PHOTO: Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 + 4 Release, Los Angeles, California, USA - 08 May 2025

Turnstile Song in New Taco Bell Commercial Featuring Tony Hawk

Turnstile, the Baltimore-based hardcore punk outfit, has managed to blend high-energy music with mainstream marketing in their latest collaboration with…

JOHN LODGE of the Moody Blues takes the crowd back in time at the Sandler Center in Virginia Beach, Virginia on 6 March 2023..photo ©Jeff Moore JOHN LODGE of the Moody Blues takes the crowd back in time at the Sandler Center in Virginia Beach, Virginia on 6 March 2023., USA - 05 Mar 2023

John Lodge Extends Tour Into December

John Lodge, the esteemed bassist of the legendary rock band the Moody Blues, has announced an extension of his 2025…

Steven Van Zandt performs with Bruce Springsteen on Day 7 of American Express Presents BST Hyde Park on July 6, 2023 in London, United, Kingdom. (Photo by Dave Hogan/Hogan Media/Shutterstock) American Express presents BST Hyde Park, Day 7, London, UK - 06 Jul 2023

Steven Van Zandt Recovering After Emergency Surgery

Renowned guitarist and actor Steven Van Zandt recently underwent emergency surgery for appendicitis, forcing him to miss several upcoming performances…

RIGHT PHOTO: AIDS Walk Atlanta & Music Festival, USA - 29 Sep 2019 LEFT PHOTO: Brandy, Apollo Spring Gala, New York, USA - 04 Jun 2018

Brandy & Monica Announce Co-Headlining ‘The Boy Is Mine’ 2025 Tour

Brandy and Monica are set to embark on a groundbreaking co-headlining tour in the fall of 2025, marking the first…

Maroon 5 - Adam Levine Maroon 5 headlines the Grand Opening of New Hard Rock Live, Hollywood, Florida, Miami, USA - 05 Oct 2019

Maroon 5 New Album Announced & Arena Tour

Maroon 5 is set to make a significant return this summer with the announcement of their much-anticipated eighth studio album,…

Axl Rose and Angus Young ACDC in concert, Vienna, Austria - 19 May 2016

AC/DC Sets 2025 Homecoming Shows

AC/DC, the iconic powerhouse of rock music, is making waves again with their much-anticipated homecoming tour, titled “PWR UP.” Set…

Eric Clapton British Summer Time Hyde Park Festival Day 3 in London, UK - 08 Jul 2018

Eric Clapton Adds Ohio Show to Tour Schedule

Eric Clapton, the legendary guitarist, is set to make a notable return to the United States with a limited series…