Everything Music. Everything News. Everything live.

Federal Judge Challenges Miley Cyrus’ Attempt to Dismiss Lawsuit

Brian Friedman / Shutterstock.com
Brian Friedman / Shutterstock.com

The legal troubles surrounding Miley Cyrus' hit song “Flowers” has intensified, casting a spotlight on the intricacies of copyright law. Last September, a suit was filed by Tempo Music Investments claiming “Flowers” included an unauthorized “exploitation” of Bruno Mars' “When I Was Your Man”. This lawsuit, lodged in a Los Angeles court, draws significant attention to the music industry's nuances, particularly how rights and revenues are managed for jointly-owned works, such as in the case of Mars' song.

It is alleged that Cyrus’s hit borrowed melody, harmony, and structural elements from Mars’ 2013 hit single. Despite Cyrus's response to the lawsuit, which asserted that Bruno Mars and his co-writers had not sued her, Tempo Music pursued its claim, emphasizing their ownership of a portion of the song through Phil Lawrence, one of Mars' co-authors. The lawsuit seeks not only damages but also an injunction to prevent Cyrus from distributing or performing “Flowers” publicly.

During the court proceedings, Judge Dean D. Pregerson expressed skepticism towards Cyrus's bid for dismissal. One key point emphasized by Cyrus's legal team is that Tempo Music, by purchasing a share from only one co-author, lacks the standing to initiate a lawsuit without the consent of Mars and the other co-authors. According to Cyrus’s attorney, Peter Anderson, this represents a critical flaw in the case against her.

Meanwhile, Tempo Music's legal counsel, Alex Weingarten, dismissed Cyrus’s argument as “intellectually dishonest,” asserting that Tempo does have the right to enforce its share of the song’s copyright. He explained that under U.S. copyright law, a co-owner can transfer rights without consent from the other co-owners and retain the right to enforce them. This perspective raises significant questions regarding the complexities of copyright ownership, especially in cases of fractional rights.

Judge Pregerson's remarks during the hearing furthered the complexity of this legal dispute, as he acknowledged the potential industry-wide implications of endorsing Cyrus’s argument. He highlighted the impact such a ruling could have on the value of sold rights, suggesting that if partial rights sales were not enforceable, it could depreciate their value considerably.

Cyrus's legal battle is not just a high-profile celebrity case; it stresses on broader issues of copyright governance and the music industry’s evolving landscape. Lasting outcomes from this case could set significant precedents for how rights are enforced, especially concerning fractional interests in jointly authored works. The court's decision could reshape legal strategies for artists and music companies alike, influencing how they approach the ownership and sale of song rights.

 

Key Takeaways

Related Stories

Carlos Santana Santana in Concert, Nashville, FirstBank Amphitheater, Franklin, USA - 29 Sep 2021

Carlos Santana Collabs With Grupo Frontera on Single Release

Carlos Santana, a rock icon with a career spanning decades, has formed a remarkable collaboration with Grupo Frontera, a prominent…

eard ZZ Top in concert at Michigan Lottery Amphitheatre, Sterling Heights, USA - 08 Sep 2019

ZZ Top Announces Return of Frank Beard

Frank Beard, the dynamic drummer of ZZ Top, is back in the thick of action with the band after a…

Brian Johnson and Angus Young of AC/DC perform at the BB&T Center, Sunrise, Florida, USA - 20 Dec 2008 AC/DC in concert, BB&T Center, Sunrise, Florida, USA - 23 Dec 2008

AC/DC Ends North American Tour in Ohio

Cleveland was the closing chapter for AC/DC’s North American “Power Up” tour, proving once again that the legendary rock band…

Electric Prunes Various

James Lowe of The Electric Prunes Dies at 82

The world of psychedelic rock mourns the loss of James Lowe, the iconic lead singer and co-founder of the Electric…

Arejay Hale, Lzzy Hale of Halestorm performs at the Boardwalk Rock Festival on May 17, 2025 in Ocean City, Maryland Halestorm performs at the Boardwalk Rock Festival on May 17, 2025 in Ocean City, Maryland, MD, USA - 17 May 2025

Halestorm Reveals Title Track ‘Everest’

Halestorm, the GRAMMY Award-winning hard rock band, is making waves in the music scene with the reveal of “Everest,” the…

Evanescence - Amy Lee Download Festival, Day 2, Donington Park, UK - 09 Jun 2023

Amy Lee of Evanescence & Halsey Release Music Video

Halsey and Amy Lee of Evanescence have joined forces to create a sensational new track, “Hand That Feeds,” which is…

Thom Yorke of The Smile Festival d'ete de Quebec, Day 9, Quebec City, Canada - 14 Jul 2023

Thom Yorke Speaks Out On Palestine & Israel Conflict

Thom Yorke, the frontman of Radiohead and The Smile, has made a public statement addressing the ongoing Israel and Palestine…

Taylor Swift wearing Dior arrives at the 2024 MTV Video Music Awards held at UBS Arena on September 11, 2024 in Elmont, New York, United States. 2024 MTV Video Music Awards - Arrivals, Ubs Arena, Elmont, New York, United States - 11 Sep 2024

Taylor Swift Regains Rights of Her Master Recordings

In a landmark move in the music industry, Taylor Swift has regained control over her master recordings. This comes after…

Goo Goo Dolls lead vocalist John Rzeznick performs at the 2025 Stagecoach Music Festival on Sunday, April 27, 2025 in Indio, CA. Stagecoach 2025 , Los Angeles, California, USA - 27 Apr 2025

Goo Goo Dolls Played at Demi Lovato’s Wedding

In a celebration as heartfelt as it was glamorous, pop star Demi Lovato tied the knot with musician Jordan “Jutes”…