Everything Music. Everything News. Everything live.

Federal Judge Challenges Miley Cyrus’ Attempt to Dismiss Lawsuit

Brian Friedman / Shutterstock.com
Brian Friedman / Shutterstock.com

The legal troubles surrounding Miley Cyrus' hit song “Flowers” has intensified, casting a spotlight on the intricacies of copyright law. Last September, a suit was filed by Tempo Music Investments claiming “Flowers” included an unauthorized “exploitation” of Bruno Mars' “When I Was Your Man”. This lawsuit, lodged in a Los Angeles court, draws significant attention to the music industry's nuances, particularly how rights and revenues are managed for jointly-owned works, such as in the case of Mars' song.

It is alleged that Cyrus’s hit borrowed melody, harmony, and structural elements from Mars’ 2013 hit single. Despite Cyrus's response to the lawsuit, which asserted that Bruno Mars and his co-writers had not sued her, Tempo Music pursued its claim, emphasizing their ownership of a portion of the song through Phil Lawrence, one of Mars' co-authors. The lawsuit seeks not only damages but also an injunction to prevent Cyrus from distributing or performing “Flowers” publicly.

During the court proceedings, Judge Dean D. Pregerson expressed skepticism towards Cyrus's bid for dismissal. One key point emphasized by Cyrus's legal team is that Tempo Music, by purchasing a share from only one co-author, lacks the standing to initiate a lawsuit without the consent of Mars and the other co-authors. According to Cyrus’s attorney, Peter Anderson, this represents a critical flaw in the case against her.

Meanwhile, Tempo Music's legal counsel, Alex Weingarten, dismissed Cyrus’s argument as “intellectually dishonest,” asserting that Tempo does have the right to enforce its share of the song’s copyright. He explained that under U.S. copyright law, a co-owner can transfer rights without consent from the other co-owners and retain the right to enforce them. This perspective raises significant questions regarding the complexities of copyright ownership, especially in cases of fractional rights.

Judge Pregerson's remarks during the hearing furthered the complexity of this legal dispute, as he acknowledged the potential industry-wide implications of endorsing Cyrus’s argument. He highlighted the impact such a ruling could have on the value of sold rights, suggesting that if partial rights sales were not enforceable, it could depreciate their value considerably.

Cyrus's legal battle is not just a high-profile celebrity case; it stresses on broader issues of copyright governance and the music industry’s evolving landscape. Lasting outcomes from this case could set significant precedents for how rights are enforced, especially concerning fractional interests in jointly authored works. The court's decision could reshape legal strategies for artists and music companies alike, influencing how they approach the ownership and sale of song rights.

 

Key Takeaways

Related Stories

Headline Act Paul McCartney performs on the Pyramid Stage during day four of Glastonbury Festival Glastonbury Festival, Day 4, UK - 25 Jun 2022

Paul McCartney Teases a 2025 Tour

In an exciting revelation that is sure to stir fans worldwide, Sir Paul McCartney is teasing the potential revival of…

Roger Waters, bassist, songwriter and former member of the rock band Pink Floyd performing on stage in Bologna, April 28, 2023, Italy, during his european tour. Photo Michele Nucci. Music Concert - Roger Waters - Farewell Tour, Bologna, Italy - 28 Apr 2023

Roger Waters Risks Jail Time During Political Protest

Roger Waters, former member of the iconic rock band Pink Floyd, finds himself at the center of legal controversy following…

David Bowie David Bowie Meltdown concert at the Royal Festival Hall, London, Britain - 29 Jun 2002

Huge New David Bowie Box Set Contains His Final Years

David Bowie’s legacy and his final years in music are being lavishly celebrated in the form of a comprehensive box…

Ronnie Wood of The Rolling Stones performs during The Rolling Stones 'Hackney Diamonds Tour' at Soldier Field in Chicago, USA - 27 June 2024 The Rolling Stones 'Hackney Diamonds Tour', Chicago, USA - 27 Jun 2024

Ronnie Wood Set to Release First Career-Spanning Compilation ‘Fearless: Anthology 1965-2025’

Renowned guitarist Ronnie Wood is being honored with a comprehensive anthology that encapsulates his illustrious 60-year career. Known for his…

Tony Levin King Crimson Festival, Crocus City Hall, Moscow, Russia - 26 May 2012

King Crimson’s in The Studio Recording a New Album

King Crimson, the illustrious progressive rock band from England, is set to release their first studio album since 2003’s *The…

Goo Goo Dolls - Johnny Rzeznik The Freezing Man Festival: Joey's Song Benefit Concert at The Sylvee in Madison, Wisconsin, USA - 11 Jan 2025

The Goo Goo Dolls Set to Headline 2025 Carousel Ball

The Goo Goo Dolls are set to headline the 39th Annual Carousel Ball, a charity gala organized by the Children’s…

LEFT PHOTO: Todd La Torre of Queensryche performs on Stage 954 at the Dania Beach Casino, Fort Lauderdale, Florida, USA - 15 Mar 2025 RIGHT PHOTO: Singer Mark Tornillo (Accept) at the Wacken Open Air in Wacken./Singer Mark Tornillo (Accept) performing at the Wacken Open Air in Wacken.

Queensrÿche Announces US 2025 Tour With Accept

Queensryche, the renowned progressive metal band, has officially announced an exciting new tour for the fall of 2025. This tour,…

MILAN, ITALY - APRIL 23: Buck Meek and Adrianne Lenker of Big Thief perform at Alcatraz Milan on April 23, 2023 in Milan, Italy. Big Thief Perform In Milan Italy - 23 Apr 2023

Big Thief Shares New Song ‘All Night All Day’

Big Thief has once again captured the music world’s attention with the release of their new single, “All Night All…

Sabrina Carpenter 67th Annual Grammy Awards, Show, Los Angeles, USA - 02 Feb 2025

Sabrina Carpenter Reveals Different Album Art From Prior Cover Controversy

Sabrina Carpenter has once again captured the media’s attention with her upcoming album “Man’s Best Friend,” which has been the…