Everything Music. Everything News. Everything live.

Miley Cyrus files motion to dismiss ‘Flowers’ lawsuit

Brian Friedman / Shutterstock.com
Brian Friedman / Shutterstock.com

In a dramatic twist in the ongoing legal saga involving Miley Cyrus's popular track “Flowers,” the singer's legal team has filed a motion seeking to dismiss a lawsuit alleging copyright infringement from Bruno Mars's hit “When I Was Your Man.” The crux of Cyrus's defense hinges on what her attorneys describe as a “fatal flaw”—the absence of Mars and his co-writers as plaintiffs in the case, raising significant debate over the entitlement to sue under copyright law.

The lawsuit, initiated by Tempo Music Investments, accuses Cyrus's song “Flowers,” which dominated the charts and earned the artist significant accolades, of copying key elements from Mars's 2013 hit. These elements include melodic and harmonic materials, specific pitch patterns, and distinctive bass-line structures. Despite the allegations, the lawsuit notably omits Mars as a plaintiff, with Tempo, having acquired a partial interest in the song's rights from co-writer Philip Lawrence, spearheading the legal action instead.

Cyrus's defense strategy, articulated by attorney Peter Anderson, emphasizes that Tempo's ownership constitutes only a non-exclusive part of the song rights, legally weakening their case. They assert that, according to U.S. copyright law, the lawsuit lacks standing without the consent and participation of all co-authors who hold exclusive rights. This procedural argument seeks to block Tempo from pursuing the infringement claims solely on their partial ownership, a standpoint that has drawn criticism from Tempo's lead counsel, Alex Weingarten. Weingarten has countered by labeling Cyrus's defense as “intellectually dishonest,” arguing that their rights entitle them to enforce the copyright.

The legal battle has garnered widespread attention, not least because “Flowers” parallels thematic elements of “When I Was Your Man.” Fans and critics have noted the lyrical similarities, with Cyrus's song serving as a defiant response to Mars's narrative of romantic regret. The chord progression and melodic structure have sparked enough debate to send Mars’s song back into streaming popularity, though music law experts like Joseph Fishman contend that Cyrus’s usage likely doesn’t infringe upon Mars’s work directly due to the lack of melody sampling.

In seeking the lawsuit's dismissal, Cyrus’s defense underscores the broader implications for copyright law and the music industry, particularly concerning joint ownership rights. The arguments presented focus heavily on the necessity of exclusive rights for initiating copyright infringement actions, a foundational criterion that Tempo’s ownership, according to Cyrus’s lawyers, does not fulfill. This point of contention could significantly influence the lawsuit’s trajectory, potentially setting precedents for future cases involving partial ownership of creative works.

Cyrus's legal maneuver not only challenges the lawsuit on technical grounds but also looks to protect her artistic work, which has gained critical and commercial success independently of Mars’s influence, they claim. The narrative of “Flowers” has resonated with audiences worldwide as an anthem of self-reliance and empowerment, adding another layer to the public discourse surrounding the lawsuit.

This case continues to unfold as both parties brace for potential court deliberations unless an out-of-court resolution emerges, making it a keenly watched conflict in the entertainment industry. Much hangs on the decision of whether Cyrus's appeal for dismissal is upheld, potentially altering the landscape of artistic ownership and rights enforcement in an era of increasingly complex media transactions.

Key Takeaways

Related Stories

MATT CAMERON of Pearl Jam during the BottleRock Music Festival in Napa, California BottleRock Music Festival 2024, Napa, California, u.s - 25 May 2024

Matt Cameron Confirms He’s Not Fully Retired, He’s ‘Still an Active Musician’

Matt Cameron, the renowned drummer for Pearl Jam and Soundgarden, recently sent shockwaves through the rock music world with his…

Al Aumuller/New York World-Telegram and the Sun (uploaded by User:Urban), Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

New Woody Guthrie Compilation Includes Recording of ‘Deportee’

A rare and culturally significant release has been announced for fans of music history and socially conscious songwriting. The release…

Iron Maiden - Nicko McBrain Sweden Rock Festival, Solvesborg, Sweden - 07 Jun 2018

Retired Iron Maiden Drummer, Nicko McBrain, Announces July 2025 Shows

Nicko McBrain, the renowned drummer from Iron Maiden, is poised to hit the stage once more, albeit in a new…

Jelly Roll CMA Fest 2025, Day 2, Nashville, Tennessee, USA - 06 Jun 2025

Jelly Roll is Not Happy with Logan Paul’s Interruption at WWE ‘Smackdown’

The intersection of music and wrestling has always offered unique entertainment dynamics, but the recent WWE SmackDown event in Nashville…

Singer Emmanuel Kelly (R), English singer Chris Martin (C) of Coldplay, US singer Doja Cat (C-L), Colombian singer J Balvin (2-L), and Nigerian singer Tems (L) perform during the halftime show of the FIFA Club World Cup 2025 Final match between Chelsea FC and Paris Saint-Germain, in East Rutherford, New Jersey, USA, 13 July 2025. FIFA Club World Cup 2025 Final - Chelsea vs PSG, East Rutherford, USA - 13 Jul 2025

Watch Coldplay & Others Perform at The FIFA World Cup Halftime Show

The FIFA Club World Cup final at MetLife Stadium in East Rutherford, New Jersey, witnessed a historic halftime show that…

Singer/musician MICHAEL MCDONALD formally of THE DOOBIE BROTHERS seen at the Ninth Annual Love Rocks NYC Benefit Concert For God's Love We Deliver held at the Beacon Theater. 9th Annual Love Rocks NYC Benefit Concert For God's Love We Deliver, New York, USA - 06 Mar 2025

Michael McDonald Wants to Be a Doobie Brother Indefinitely

Michael McDonald, an iconic figure in the rock music scene, has been a quintessential part of The Doobie Brothers. His…

Kevin Parke of the psychedelic music project band, Tame Impala NOS Primavera Sound Festival, Porto, Portugal - 09 Jun 2022

Tame Impala Teases New Music on Social Media

Tame Impala’s Kevin Parker is creating a buzz in the music world with hints of new material. Recent updates across…

This Is Spinal Tap, David Kaff, Christopher Guest

Spinal Tap Keyboardist, David Kaff, Dies at 79

Recently, the music world bid farewell to David Kaff, a versatile musician and actor most renowned for his role as…

Don Barnes, 38 Special in concert at Celebrate Virginia Live!, Fredericksburg, Virginia, America - 20 May 2011

38 Special to Release First Album in Over 20 Years

In a spectacular culmination of five decades in the music industry, legendary southern rock band 38 Special is celebrating its…