Everything Music. Everything News. Everything live.

Yes Lead Singer Responds to Former Bandmate’s Lawsuit

Rick Dikeman, CC BY-SA 3.0 <http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/>, via Wikimedia Commons
Rick Dikeman, CC BY-SA 3.0 , via Wikimedia Commons

The renowned progressive rock band Yes is embroiled in a legal controversy following allegations of copyright infringement related to their track “Dare to Know” from the 2021 album *The Quest*. The lawsuit, filed by musician Riz Story, also known as Rudolph Zahler, accuses Yes members Steve Howe and Jon Davison of incorporating elements from Zahler's composition “Reunion” without permission. “Reunion” is a song featured in the 2014 indie film *A Winter Rose*, which starred notable actors such as Paul Sorvino and Billy Zane. Zahler, who claims he had a longstanding friendship with Davison, asserts that the latter had access to “Reunion” and used it in the creation of “Dare to Know.”

Riz Story's allegations gain complexity given the personal history shared between him and Davison. The two musicians, along with the late Foo Fighters' drummer Taylor Hawkins, formed part of a prog-rock band in their early careers. Zahler contends that he was instrumental in facilitating Davison's entry into Yes and had even worked on co-writing songs for the band. This backdrop of previous collaborations adds a layer of intrigue to the copyright dispute, suggesting a betrayal of personal and professional trust. Zahler's suit further claims that Davison acclaimed “Reunion” for its musical composition during discussions about *A Winter Rose*, indicating preceding awareness and possible appropriation of Zahler's work.

The defense mounted by the band and Davison vehemently denies these allegations, labeling the lawsuit as “vindictive” and “defamatory.” In an official statement, Yes's representative brands the claims as “delusional garbage” that they intend to defend rigorously. Davison underscores his unfamiliarity with the song “Reunion” and denies seeing the movie, claiming that any appreciation expressed for Zahler's work was purely out of courtesy. Additional support in their defense is drawn from what they claim is flawed musicological analysis cited in the lawsuit, which states a striking musical similarity between “Reunion” and “Dare to Know,” arguing that the findings were manipulated to falsely indicate imitation.

A separate aspect of interest is the role of Sony Music Entertainment and Inside Out Music, named as co-defendants, attributed to their participation in the album's release. The suit not only seeks financial compensation but also requests the legal attribution of songwriting credits for “Dare to Know” in favor of Zahler. Story's legal representative, Larry J. Caldwell, expresses a poignant disappointment in having to confront a childhood idol and longtime friend in court but maintains confidence in the legal system to achieve a just resolution. This narrative raises questions about the broader implications of creative ownership and rights within the music industry, particularly among artists with shared histories.

Adding to the layers of this controversy is a historical context concerning the band's dealings with intellectual property. Yes previously updated credits on another track, “The Ice Bridge,” after fans noted similarities to a composition by Francis Monkman. This prior incident, acknowledged via a statement by Yes member Geoff Downes on social media, unintentionally invites skepticism regarding the band's practices related to creative sourcing and attribution.

 

Key Takeaways

Related Stories

Kate Nash Birmingham Pride, UK - 25 May 2019

Kate Nash Unveils Powerful New Single ‘GERM’

Kate Nash, renowned for her ability to intertwine social commentary with catchy melodies, has once again ignited conversations with her…

Caleb Followill of Kings of Leon iHeartRadio ALTer EGO, Show, The Forum, Los Angeles, California, USA - 15 Jan 2022

Kings of Leon Cancels UK/European Dates Due To ‘Freak Accident’

Kings of Leon, a prominent name in the rock music scene, recently announced the unfortunate cancellation of their much-anticipated UK…

Jason Bonham of Jason Bonham's Led Zeppelin Experience performs at Hard Rock Live held at the Seminole Hard Rock Hotel and Casino, Hollywood, Florida, USA - 12 Nov 2023 Jason Bonham's Led Zeppelin Experience in concert, Hard Rock Live held, Seminole Hard Rock Hotel and Casino, Hollywood, Florida, USA - 12 Nov 2023

Jason Bonham Extends Tour & Adds North American Dates

Jason Bonham’s Led Zeppelin Evening is amplifying its celebration of the 50th anniversary of Led Zeppelin’s eminent album “Physical Graffiti”…

Billy Strings Austin City Limits Music Festival, Weekend 1, Day 3, Texas, USA - 06 Oct 2019

Billy Strings Returns To The 2025 Bluegrass Festival

The rise of Billy Strings in the bluegrass world has been nothing short of phenomenal, marked by both his musical…

John Butler Trio performs during the Solidays festival in Paris, France, on June 22, 2019. 2019 Solidays Festival - Paris, France - 22 Jun 2019

John Butler Announces New Solo Album ‘PRISM’

John Butler, the renowned Australian musician, is poised for an impactful return with the release of his new solo album,…

Thom Yorke of The Smile Festival d'ete de Quebec, Day 9, Quebec City, Canada - 14 Jul 2023

Thom Yorke Releases New Song “Dialing In”

Thom Yorke, the iconic frontman of Radiohead and The Smile, has unveiled a new track entitled “Dialing In,” which serves…

Bono attending the "Bono: Stories Of Surrender" red carpet at the 78th annual Cannes Film Festival at Palais des Festivals on May 16, 2025 in Cannes, France. "Bono: Stories Of Surrender" Red Carpet - 78th Annual Cannes Film Festival, France - 16 May 2025

Bono Supports Springsteen Saying ‘There’s Only One Boss in America’

In a recent series of media appearances, U2’s Bono has become a vocal ally of Bruce Springsteen in the ongoing…

Tim Mcilrath Lead Singer and Guitarist of the Chicago-based Melodic Hardcore Band Rise Against Performs During Their Concert at the Annual Volt Festival in Sopron 208 Kms West of Budapest Hungary 02 July 2015 the Festival Runs From 01 to 04 July 2015 and Presents International Acts on 15 Stages Hungary Sopron Hungary Music Festival - Jul 2015

Rise Against Announces First New Album In Four Years

In a significant return, Chicago’s punk rock stalwarts, Rise Against, have announced their first album in over four years, titled…

James "J.Y." Young and Tommy Shaw of Styx perform at Hard Rock Live held at the Seminole Hard Rock Hotel & Casino, Hollywood, Florida, USA - 12 Jan 2025 Styx in concert at Hard Rock Live held at the Seminole Hard Rock Hotel & Casino, Hollywood, Florida, USA - 12 Jan 2025

Styx Confirms New Concept Album

Rock legends Styx are set to make waves again with their latest studio effort, “Circling From Above.” This album represents…