Everything Music. Everything News. Everything live.

Yes Lead Singer Responds to Former Bandmate’s Lawsuit

Rick Dikeman, CC BY-SA 3.0 <http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/>, via Wikimedia Commons
Rick Dikeman, CC BY-SA 3.0 , via Wikimedia Commons

The renowned progressive rock band Yes is embroiled in a legal controversy following allegations of copyright infringement related to their track “Dare to Know” from the 2021 album *The Quest*. The lawsuit, filed by musician Riz Story, also known as Rudolph Zahler, accuses Yes members Steve Howe and Jon Davison of incorporating elements from Zahler's composition “Reunion” without permission. “Reunion” is a song featured in the 2014 indie film *A Winter Rose*, which starred notable actors such as Paul Sorvino and Billy Zane. Zahler, who claims he had a longstanding friendship with Davison, asserts that the latter had access to “Reunion” and used it in the creation of “Dare to Know.”

Riz Story's allegations gain complexity given the personal history shared between him and Davison. The two musicians, along with the late Foo Fighters' drummer Taylor Hawkins, formed part of a prog-rock band in their early careers. Zahler contends that he was instrumental in facilitating Davison's entry into Yes and had even worked on co-writing songs for the band. This backdrop of previous collaborations adds a layer of intrigue to the copyright dispute, suggesting a betrayal of personal and professional trust. Zahler's suit further claims that Davison acclaimed “Reunion” for its musical composition during discussions about *A Winter Rose*, indicating preceding awareness and possible appropriation of Zahler's work.

The defense mounted by the band and Davison vehemently denies these allegations, labeling the lawsuit as “vindictive” and “defamatory.” In an official statement, Yes's representative brands the claims as “delusional garbage” that they intend to defend rigorously. Davison underscores his unfamiliarity with the song “Reunion” and denies seeing the movie, claiming that any appreciation expressed for Zahler's work was purely out of courtesy. Additional support in their defense is drawn from what they claim is flawed musicological analysis cited in the lawsuit, which states a striking musical similarity between “Reunion” and “Dare to Know,” arguing that the findings were manipulated to falsely indicate imitation.

A separate aspect of interest is the role of Sony Music Entertainment and Inside Out Music, named as co-defendants, attributed to their participation in the album's release. The suit not only seeks financial compensation but also requests the legal attribution of songwriting credits for “Dare to Know” in favor of Zahler. Story's legal representative, Larry J. Caldwell, expresses a poignant disappointment in having to confront a childhood idol and longtime friend in court but maintains confidence in the legal system to achieve a just resolution. This narrative raises questions about the broader implications of creative ownership and rights within the music industry, particularly among artists with shared histories.

Adding to the layers of this controversy is a historical context concerning the band's dealings with intellectual property. Yes previously updated credits on another track, “The Ice Bridge,” after fans noted similarities to a composition by Francis Monkman. This prior incident, acknowledged via a statement by Yes member Geoff Downes on social media, unintentionally invites skepticism regarding the band's practices related to creative sourcing and attribution.

 

Key Takeaways

Related Stories

The National - Matt Berninger The National in concert at Castlefield Bowl, Manchester, UK - 04 Jul 2024

The National’s Matt Berninger Shares New Track Off Solo Album

Matt Berninger, the eminent frontman of The National, is carving a distinct path with his solo musical endeavors, which include…

Brad Arnold of the band 3 Doors Down performs at Credit Union 1 Amphitheatre on Saturday, June 17, 2023, in Tinley Park, Ill. 3 Doors Down, with Candlebox, in concert, Credit Union 1 Amphitheatre, Tinley Park, Illinois, USA - 17 Jun 2023

Brad Arnold of 3 Doors Down is Diagnosed With Stage 4 Kidney Cancer

Brad Arnold, the lead singer of the rock band 3 Doors Down, has publicly announced through a heartfelt video on…

LEFT PHOTO: CC BY 2.0 , via Wikimedia Commons RIGHT PHOTO: CC BY-SA 4.0 , via Wikimedia Commons

Tool’s Adam Jones Performs for WWE Wrestler Penta’s New Entrance

In an exciting and dynamic crossover between the worlds of professional wrestling and heavy metal music, WWE wrestler Penta, also…

Rock band: The Who - lead vocalist Roger Daltrey, guitarist Pete Townshend, and drummer Keith Moon VARIOUS

The Who Teases Upcoming ‘The Song is Over’ Project

The renowned rock band The Who has once again captivated their audience with an intriguing announcement of their new project,…

Soundgarden - Chris Cornell SoundGarden In Concert, Whisky a Go Go, Los Angeles, USA - 07 Dec 1989

Soundgarden Plans to Release Last Album With Late Frontman, Chris Cornell

Soundgarden, one of the pioneering bands of the grunge movement, is moving forward with plans to release a final album…

LEFT PHOTO: 2005 Lollapalooza Day 2 Nathan Jerde of the Ponys RIGHT PHOTO: 2005 Lollapalooza Day 2 Nathan Jerde of the Ponys

Drummer, Nathan Jerde of The Ponys Has Died

Nathan Jerde, the talented drummer for the Chicago indie-rock band The Ponys, has passed away, leaving a significant void in…

Svenska: Katatonia på Grammisgalan på Cirkus, Stockholm den 20 februari 2013. Date 20 February 2013

Katatonia Unveils New Single ‘Temporal’

Swedish melancholic metal band Katatonia has once again captivated their audience with the release of their second single, “Temporal,” from…

Parkway Drive in concert @ Download Festival England 16.06.24 2024 Download Festival, Day 3, Donington Park, Leicestershire, UK - 16 Jun 2024

Parkway Drive Shares First New Single In Three Years

Australia’s renowned metalcore band, Parkway Drive, has returned with their latest single, “Sacred,” a musical piece that exudes both power…

Entertainer Jay-Z stands on the sideline with daughters Blue Ivy (L) and Rumi before the Philadelphia Eagles defeat the Kansas City Chiefs 40-22 in Super Bowl LIX at Caesars Superdome in New Orleans on Sunday, February 9, 2025. Super Bowl Lix, New Orleans, Louisiana, United States - 09 Feb 2025

Jay-Z Claims Accuser is Still Making ‘Malicious’ Statements

Jay-Z, a renowned musician and entrepreneur, is currently embroiled in a legal battle that has brought significant economic and reputational…