Everything Music. Everything News. Everything live.

Yes Lead Singer Responds to Former Bandmate’s Lawsuit

Rick Dikeman, CC BY-SA 3.0 <http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/>, via Wikimedia Commons
Rick Dikeman, CC BY-SA 3.0 , via Wikimedia Commons

The renowned progressive rock band Yes is embroiled in a legal controversy following allegations of copyright infringement related to their track “Dare to Know” from the 2021 album *The Quest*. The lawsuit, filed by musician Riz Story, also known as Rudolph Zahler, accuses Yes members Steve Howe and Jon Davison of incorporating elements from Zahler's composition “Reunion” without permission. “Reunion” is a song featured in the 2014 indie film *A Winter Rose*, which starred notable actors such as Paul Sorvino and Billy Zane. Zahler, who claims he had a longstanding friendship with Davison, asserts that the latter had access to “Reunion” and used it in the creation of “Dare to Know.”

Riz Story's allegations gain complexity given the personal history shared between him and Davison. The two musicians, along with the late Foo Fighters' drummer Taylor Hawkins, formed part of a prog-rock band in their early careers. Zahler contends that he was instrumental in facilitating Davison's entry into Yes and had even worked on co-writing songs for the band. This backdrop of previous collaborations adds a layer of intrigue to the copyright dispute, suggesting a betrayal of personal and professional trust. Zahler's suit further claims that Davison acclaimed “Reunion” for its musical composition during discussions about *A Winter Rose*, indicating preceding awareness and possible appropriation of Zahler's work.

The defense mounted by the band and Davison vehemently denies these allegations, labeling the lawsuit as “vindictive” and “defamatory.” In an official statement, Yes's representative brands the claims as “delusional garbage” that they intend to defend rigorously. Davison underscores his unfamiliarity with the song “Reunion” and denies seeing the movie, claiming that any appreciation expressed for Zahler's work was purely out of courtesy. Additional support in their defense is drawn from what they claim is flawed musicological analysis cited in the lawsuit, which states a striking musical similarity between “Reunion” and “Dare to Know,” arguing that the findings were manipulated to falsely indicate imitation.

A separate aspect of interest is the role of Sony Music Entertainment and Inside Out Music, named as co-defendants, attributed to their participation in the album's release. The suit not only seeks financial compensation but also requests the legal attribution of songwriting credits for “Dare to Know” in favor of Zahler. Story's legal representative, Larry J. Caldwell, expresses a poignant disappointment in having to confront a childhood idol and longtime friend in court but maintains confidence in the legal system to achieve a just resolution. This narrative raises questions about the broader implications of creative ownership and rights within the music industry, particularly among artists with shared histories.

Adding to the layers of this controversy is a historical context concerning the band's dealings with intellectual property. Yes previously updated credits on another track, “The Ice Bridge,” after fans noted similarities to a composition by Francis Monkman. This prior incident, acknowledged via a statement by Yes member Geoff Downes on social media, unintentionally invites skepticism regarding the band's practices related to creative sourcing and attribution.

 

Key Takeaways

Related Stories

Headline Act Paul McCartney performs on the Pyramid Stage during day four of Glastonbury Festival Glastonbury Festival, Day 4, UK - 25 Jun 2022

Paul McCartney Teases a 2025 Tour

In an exciting revelation that is sure to stir fans worldwide, Sir Paul McCartney is teasing the potential revival of…

Roger Waters, bassist, songwriter and former member of the rock band Pink Floyd performing on stage in Bologna, April 28, 2023, Italy, during his european tour. Photo Michele Nucci. Music Concert - Roger Waters - Farewell Tour, Bologna, Italy - 28 Apr 2023

Roger Waters Risks Jail Time During Political Protest

Roger Waters, former member of the iconic rock band Pink Floyd, finds himself at the center of legal controversy following…

David Bowie David Bowie Meltdown concert at the Royal Festival Hall, London, Britain - 29 Jun 2002

Huge New David Bowie Box Set Contains His Final Years

David Bowie’s legacy and his final years in music are being lavishly celebrated in the form of a comprehensive box…

Ronnie Wood of The Rolling Stones performs during The Rolling Stones 'Hackney Diamonds Tour' at Soldier Field in Chicago, USA - 27 June 2024 The Rolling Stones 'Hackney Diamonds Tour', Chicago, USA - 27 Jun 2024

Ronnie Wood Set to Release First Career-Spanning Compilation ‘Fearless: Anthology 1965-2025’

Renowned guitarist Ronnie Wood is being honored with a comprehensive anthology that encapsulates his illustrious 60-year career. Known for his…

Tony Levin King Crimson Festival, Crocus City Hall, Moscow, Russia - 26 May 2012

King Crimson’s in The Studio Recording a New Album

King Crimson, the illustrious progressive rock band from England, is set to release their first studio album since 2003’s *The…

Goo Goo Dolls - Johnny Rzeznik The Freezing Man Festival: Joey's Song Benefit Concert at The Sylvee in Madison, Wisconsin, USA - 11 Jan 2025

The Goo Goo Dolls Set to Headline 2025 Carousel Ball

The Goo Goo Dolls are set to headline the 39th Annual Carousel Ball, a charity gala organized by the Children’s…

LEFT PHOTO: Todd La Torre of Queensryche performs on Stage 954 at the Dania Beach Casino, Fort Lauderdale, Florida, USA - 15 Mar 2025 RIGHT PHOTO: Singer Mark Tornillo (Accept) at the Wacken Open Air in Wacken./Singer Mark Tornillo (Accept) performing at the Wacken Open Air in Wacken.

Queensrÿche Announces US 2025 Tour With Accept

Queensryche, the renowned progressive metal band, has officially announced an exciting new tour for the fall of 2025. This tour,…

MILAN, ITALY - APRIL 23: Buck Meek and Adrianne Lenker of Big Thief perform at Alcatraz Milan on April 23, 2023 in Milan, Italy. Big Thief Perform In Milan Italy - 23 Apr 2023

Big Thief Shares New Song ‘All Night All Day’

Big Thief has once again captured the music world’s attention with the release of their new single, “All Night All…

Sabrina Carpenter 67th Annual Grammy Awards, Show, Los Angeles, USA - 02 Feb 2025

Sabrina Carpenter Reveals Different Album Art From Prior Cover Controversy

Sabrina Carpenter has once again captured the media’s attention with her upcoming album “Man’s Best Friend,” which has been the…