Geddy Lee Calls Out Drummers Who Pushed to Replace Neil Peart After His Death

In a new Guitar World interview, Lee says the opportunistic outreach came while he and Alex Lifeson were still grieving their bandmate.

Geddy Lee has revealed that numerous drummers contacted him in the immediate aftermath of Neil Peart’s January 2020 death to push themselves as potential replacements in Rush, calling the behavior ‘completely inappropriate timing.’ Speaking with Guitar World, Lee drew a sharp distinction between close friends in the drumming world, who he said showed proper respect, and a wider group of musicians whose opportunistic outreach he found deeply offensive.

Lee Separates Friends From Opportunists

Lee was direct about the divide he observed. Drummers who were genuine friends of the band, he explained, understood the gravity of the moment. ‘People who are close to us, good friends that are successful drummers, would never infer something like that because they have too much respect, not only for Neil and for the situation,’ he told Guitar World. Those friends, he added, were grieving alongside him and Lifeson and would not have been ‘so selfish as to say something inappropriate like that.’

The wider group of drummers who did reach out received no such grace from Lee. ‘There were many other drummers who reached out to me in the aftermath of Neil’s passing that were pushing themselves, and that was most distasteful to me,’ he said, describing the behavior as ‘completely inappropriate timing.’ Lee did not name any of the individuals involved.

Peart’s Death and the Long Road Back

Peart died after a three-and-a-half-year battle with glioblastoma, an aggressive form of brain cancer. Rush had already been inactive for several years following the conclusion of their farewell tour in 2015, and his death made the band’s future seem definitively closed. Given Peart’s singular status in rock drumming history, the idea of continuing Rush with anyone else was, for most observers, unthinkable.

The first sign that Lee and Lifeson were willing to revisit that question came at the Taylor Hawkins tribute concert in 2022, where the two performed together. Over time, as they continued making music, they began to consider whether a proper reunion was possible, framed around celebrating their career and honoring Peart’s legacy.

How Anika Nilles Got the Call

When Lee and Lifeson did begin looking for a drummer, they had no formal shortlist. Nilles came to their attention through a recommendation, and according to one source, the tip came from a tech who had worked alongside her in the Jeff Beck Group. Lee said he had also done his own research on her before they made contact. ‘We started with Anika because she had been recommended to me and I had done some research on her. I loved her vibe and diverse style,’ he said.

Early rehearsals were not without friction. Lifeson has spoken separately about a difficult initial period, noting, ‘It wasn’t quite working with the three of us. We were thinking that maybe we should continue with someone else, just to see how that might feel.’ The turning point came on the fifth day of rehearsals. Lifeson described the shift: ‘She took all our comments about feel, about Neil’s feel and the way he played, and being very cognisant of the ability that he had, and bang! She nailed the songs all day. It was a real Wow! moment.’

Lee’s assessment of what Nilles ultimately brought to the table went beyond technical ability. ‘She brought a lot to the table, but more than her chops, more than her guts and her willingness to sit in that hot seat, she brought an intelligence and a story,’ he said.

Tour Details: North America and Beyond

Rush’s reunion tour, celebrating the band’s 50th anniversary, launches June 7 in Los Angeles. Demand was strong enough that the run was extended multiple times, pushing the total number of planned North American dates to more than 50 and keeping the band on the road from June through December. Rock keyboardist Loren Gold will also join the touring lineup.

International dates are planned for the following year, with stops lined up across South America and Europe.

• Argentina
• Brazil
• Germany
• Netherlands
• United Kingdom
• Poland
• Italy
• Switzerland
• Norway
• Denmark
• Sweden
• Finland

What we know

• Geddy Lee told Guitar World that many drummers contacted him after Neil Peart’s death in January 2020 to push themselves as replacements, behavior he called ‘most distasteful’ and ‘completely inappropriate timing.’
• Neil Peart died after a three-and-a-half-year battle with glioblastoma, an aggressive form of brain cancer.
• Lee and Alex Lifeson first performed together again at the Taylor Hawkins tribute concert in 2022.
• Anika Nilles was recommended to Lee and came to the band’s attention partly through a tech who had worked with her in the Jeff Beck Group.
• Alex Lifeson said early rehearsals with Nilles were difficult and the band considered moving on to another drummer, but on the fifth day she ‘nailed the songs all day,’ which Lifeson called a ‘real Wow! moment.’
• The North American reunion tour opens June 7 in Los Angeles and has been extended to more than 50 dates, running from June to December.
• Rock keyboardist Loren Gold will join Rush on the tour.

The take

Neil Peart occupies a position in rock drumming that has few real parallels. Widely regarded as one of the greatest drummers in the history of the genre, he was so central to Rush’s identity that his death effectively ended the band in most fans’ minds before Lee and Lifeson had even processed the loss. The opportunistic outreach Lee describes is, unfortunately, a pattern that surfaces around major rock vacancies; similar stories have circulated around other legendary bands following the deaths or departures of irreplaceable members. What makes Lee’s account notable is the candor with which he names the behavior and the clear moral line he draws between the drumming community’s inner circle and its periphery.

The choice of Anika Nilles is itself significant. She is a respected figure in contemporary drumming circles, known for a style that blends technical precision with musicality, and her background is far removed from the classic rock world Rush inhabits. That distance may have been part of the appeal. Bringing in someone who was not already defined by the classic rock canon gave the reunion a creative rationale beyond nostalgia. Lifeson’s account of the fifth-day rehearsal breakthrough also suggests the band was genuinely rigorous in the process rather than simply filling a seat. For a legacy act carrying the weight of Peart’s reputation, that kind of deliberateness matters enormously to the fanbase.

Why it matters

For Rush fans, the reunion has always carried an emotional complexity that most rock comebacks do not. Peart was irreplaceable by any reasonable measure, and the decision to continue under the Rush name with a new drummer was always going to invite scrutiny. Lee’s account of the selection process, and his willingness to call out the musicians who treated Peart’s death as a career opportunity, gives the reunion a moral grounding that will resonate with a fanbase that holds Peart in genuine reverence. It also signals that Lee and Lifeson approached this carefully rather than rushing to fill the void.

What’s next

The North American leg of Rush’s 50th anniversary reunion tour begins June 7 in Los Angeles, with more than 50 dates scheduled through December. International touring is planned for the following year, with confirmed regions including South America and multiple European countries. Full dates and ticket information are available on the band’s website.

Frequently asked questions

Related coverage

• Dave Mustaine Says He Has No Interest in Keeping Metallica Feud Alive
• Dave Grohl Calls Out ‘D.O.A.’ Lyric as Foo Fighters’ Cringiest Line
• Rod Stewart Says 2027 UK Tour Will ‘Probably’ Be His Last on the Road