Everything Music. Everything News. Everything live.

Primus Returns to Stage for First Show Since Drummer’s Departure

Ismael Quintanilla III / Shutterstock.com
Ismael Quintanilla III / Shutterstock.com

Primus has made a triumphant return to the stage following the unexpected departure of their longtime drummer, Tim ‘Herb' Alexander. The band's first performance without Alexander was held on December 30th at the Fox Theater in Oakland, California, as part of their New Year's Eve celebration shows. With Alexander having abruptly left the band after stating his need to focus on his mental and physical health, Primus had to make quick adjustments to their lineup and came up with an exciting solution that delighted fans.

In a nostalgic twist, the band was joined by a familiar face at drums, Bryan ‘Brain' Mantia, who had previously filled the role during Alexander's earlier hiatus from 1996 until 2000. Mantia's return brought a wave of excitement as he has a cherished history with the band, having been part of several crucial Primus albums, including “Brown Album” and “Antipop”. His unexpected appearance at this pivotal concert served as a bridge for fans who had been following the band's dynamic journey over the years.

The event was more than just a typical concert; it was a celebration of Les Claypool's expansive career. Opening performances by Claypool's side projects, Holy Mackerel and Frog Brigade, set the stage for an epic night. Musicians from these bands also joined Primus for parts of their set, showcasing the fluid musical collaborations that define Claypool's artistic vision. The night featured not only iconic Primus hits like ‘Those Damned Blue-Collar Tweekers' and ‘Fisticuffs' but also revived tracks such as ‘Restin' Bones', played live for the first time since 1997, demonstrating Primus’s commitment to exploring their musical past while forging ahead into the future.

The personnel change was a necessity due to Alexander's decision to step back, explained in a heartfelt message where he expressed feeling overwhelmed and needing to prioritize his mental and family well-being. Fans received this news with mixed emotions, acknowledging the loss but also understanding the personal nature of Alexander's decision. The introduction of Mantia as a temporary yet symbolic figure behind the drum kit allowed the band to march forward without losing momentum.

Primus's ambition to fill the vacant drummer position permanently has led them to open auditions with a unique focus on groove, pocket awareness, and the ability to contribute creatively to the band's dynamic sound. Les Claypool and his colleagues have emphasized that they're not just looking for technical proficiency but for someone who can seamlessly integrate into the band’s idiosyncratic style and ethos. This search is ongoing, and fans are eagerly anticipating who will become the next permanent member of this iconic group.

Going forward, Primus has scheduled performances at several high-profile events, including ‘Tool: Live In The Sand’ festival in March, showcasing Danny Carey of Tool as a guest drummer. Later in the year, they are set to embark on the ‘Sessanta V2.0 Tour’ alongside A Perfect Circle and Puscifer, marking a vibrant period for the band as they continue to redefine their place in the rock and alternative scenes.

Key Takeaways

Related Stories

Dave Grohl from the US rock band 'Foo Fighters' performs at The Town 2023 music festival in Sao Paulo, Brazil, 09 September 2023. The Town 2023 music festival in Sao Paulo, Brazil - 09 Sep 2023

Foo Fighters Release New Song ‘Today’s Song’

The Foo Fighters are commemorating their 30th anniversary with the release of a compelling new single, “Today’s Song.” This track…

P DIDDY MTV AWARDS, BARCELONA, SPAIN - 14 NOV 2002

Sean “Diddy” Combs Guilty of Prostitution Charges, But Not of Racketeering & Sex Trafficking

Sean “Diddy” Combs, a towering figure in the hip-hop industry, recently faced a legal battle that captured widespread media and…

Bret Michaels performs during the Parti-Gras Holiday celebration at The Pompano Beach Amphitheater, Pompano Beach, Florida, USA - 07 Dec 2024 Parti-Gras Holiday celebration at The Pompano Beach Amphitheater, Pompano Beach, Florida, USA - 07 Dec 2024

Bret Michaels Changes Tour Schedule After Health Scare

Bret Michaels, the iconic frontman of the rock band Poison, recently faced a challenging health scare that has caused a…

Rob Halford lead of the British band Judas Priest performing on stage as part of the Monster of Rock Tour at Mexico City Arena. on May 4, 2025 in Mexico City, Mexico. (Photo by Carlos Santiago/ Eyepix Group) Judas Priest and Opeth 'Monster of Rock' Concert, Mexico City, Mexico - 04 May 2025

Judas Priest Covers Black Sabbath’s ‘War Pigs’

Judas Priest, a pioneering force in the heavy metal genre, recently paid homage to their fellow Birmingham natives, Black Sabbath,…

Aerosmith, Steven Tyler and Joe Perry in Sao Paulo, Brazil - Jan 1994 VARIOUS

Joe Perry Opens Up About Possibility of Final Aerosmith Concert

Joe Perry, the legendary guitarist from Aerosmith, has sparked discussions about a possible reunion for a final show. Despite announcing…

Irish musician Bono of the band U2 performs in Khreshatyk metro station in Kyiv (Kiev), Ukraine, 08 May 2022, to support Ukraine in the conflict with Russia. Western countries have responded with various sets of sanctions against Russian state majority owned companies and interests in a bid to bring an end to the conflict. Russian troops entered Ukraine on 24 February, resulting in fighting and destruction in the country. Irish musician Bono of U2 performs in metro station in Kyiv, Ukraine - 08 May 2022

Bono Slams Trump’s Gutting of USAID

In a significant and emotional discourse, former Presidents Barack Obama and George W. Bush along with U2’s lead singer Bono…

LEFT PHOTO: Dwayne Johnson, 'Moana 2' film premiere, London, UK - 24 Nov 2024 RIGHT PHOTO: Jelly Roll, 60th Academy of Country Music Awards, Arrivals, Frisco, Texas, USA - 08 May 2025

The Rock Finally Hugs Jelly Roll After Singer’s Music Helped Him Through Dark Times

In an inspiring tale of friendship and the power of music, Hollywood actor Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson and country singer…

Green Day - Billie Joe Armstrong KROQ ALMOST ACCOUSTIC CHRISTMAS CONCERT, DAY TWO, LOS ANGELES, AMERICA - 12 DEC 2004

Green Day Fan Invited On Stage to Play ‘Good Riddance,’ But Plays ‘Wonderwall’ Instead

In what seemed like a routine Green Day concert in Luxembourg on June 30, 2025, an unexpected twist turned the…

Scooter Braun arrives on the red carpet at the NY special screening event for Amazon Prime's upcoming doc Justin Bieber: Our World Special Screening in New York, United States - 14 Sep 2021

Scooter Braun Steps Down as CEO of HYBE America

Scooter Braun, a prominent figure in the music industry known for managing stars like Justin Bieber and Ariana Grande, is…